Dr Buti Refutes Imkan alKidhb

https://www.naseemalsham.com/fatwas/view/9094

 

https://web.archive.org/web/20100608232625/www.naseem-alsham.com/fatwa.php?CID=1&ID=2579


نسب إلى فضيلتكم في أحد المواقع القول بأن الكذب في حق الله تعالى ليس مستحيلاً ذاتياً وأنه تحت قدرته. ولكنه تعالى أوجب على نفسه أن لا يكذب. وهذا القول ترجم إلى الإنكليزية ونريد أن نتأكد منكم مدى صحة نسبة هذا القول إليكم
أجاب عنه: أ.د.محمد سعيد رمضان البوطي

إن أحداً لم يوجه إليّ هذا السؤال. وأعتقد أن أحداً لم يواجهني ولن يواجهني بمثل هذه السفالة في السؤال.
ليس في الناس من يجهل أن الكذب من الصفات الذميمة.
وليس في المؤمنين بالله من يجهل أن الله متصف بصفات الكمال كلها ومنزه عن سائر صفات النقصان. وقدرته جل جلاله على شيء ما لا يعني بالضرورة إمكان اتصافه به. على أن قدرته إنما تتعلق بالممكنات ولا تتعلق بالمستحيلات.
محمد سعيد رمضان البوطي

 

Will this amjad say this at Ghamkol and defend these insults tomorrow night from the pulpit?

 

Amjad from Birmingham has texed a brother this today about the Deobandi insults

'I dont believe they said them the way brillos have made it out

Read faisla kun munazara,u will c wonders'

 

'The Masjid was the vision of Hazrat Sufi Mohammed Abdullah Khan Sahib, Khalifah-e-Azam Darbar-i-Alia Ghamkol Sharif. It was built with his help, guidance, and supervision. The foundation of the Masjid was laid on 15th March 1992 by students of Dar Ul Uloom Islamia Rizvia (supplementary school) during the Holy month of Ramadan'

http://en-gb.facebook.com/pages/Cen...rif-Birmingham-Events/172862942762516?sk=info

The organiser has been going around mocking ala Hazrat and stating that he tampered with texts etc, stating he has no issue with the deobandi insults

Sad that an institute aligning itself with Imam Ahmad Raza Khan allow him to organise an event. He should be summoned to Hazrat Sufi Saab and explain what he has been saying.

He could admit that the above accusation is true or do taqiah and deny it

 

http://www.naseemalsham.com/en/Pages.php?page=readFatwa&pg_id=9094

 

It's sad that there is a Urs being organised for the late Shaykh by a chap who is going around confused on the Imkan issue (he cannot make his mind up on the issue) and has also been trying to defend the deobandi insults.

He is confused as Keller on the issue yet tries to insult ala Hazrat and call him a Takfiri. The idiot eats from Sunnis and takes a Salary from Sunnis yet calls them derogatory names

I think he is trying to get back at a Sufi Tariqa in Birmingham who ousted his friends from their zawiya.

 

difficult was the way, but there were lamps on the roads
now the city is close, walk a little more with me.

(quick rough translation)

 

Translation?

 

The following thread should be made a sticky somewhere and this current thread about Shaykh Ramadan al Bouti should be stuck on the end:

http://masabih.org/showthread.php?t=2922

 

Answer by Dr. Muĥammad, Saˆiid Ramađaan Al-Buuţiyy: No one has ever asked me about this, and I believe that no one has ever faced me, nor will anyone ever face me with such a despicable question.
There is no one among the people that does not know that lying belongs to the category of lowly attributes. Moreover, there is no one among the believers in Allaah that does not know that Allaah is only attributed with complete perfection, and that He is clear of all attributes of flaw. Furthermore, something pertaining to the Power of Allaah does not mean it is possible that Allaah could be attributed with it. Finally, His Power pertains only to what is possible, and does not pertain to what is impossible.
Muĥammad Saˆiid Ramađaan Al-Buuţiyy

 

sheikh Abu Adam's translation (hafizdhahullaah)

http://sunnianswers.wordpress.com/2010/06/06/perversion-by-those-who-claim-allaah-could-lie-exposed/

i hope insha Allah something comes forward from the glorious Habaib too.

 

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?1166-Imkan-Kadhib

Faqir, this shows your friend faraz rabbani has making things up once again. These Devbandits are Kazabiyya .

May Allah Protect us from them.

 

It has been attributed to your nobility on one of the many websites the saying that kidhb (lying) in the right of Allah Most High is not intrinsically impossible and it is under his power, but the Most High as obligated upon Himself not to lie. This attributed saying was then translated to English. We want to be certain from you regarding the authenticity of this attribution.

DR BUTI REPLIES: Surely no one has made me aware of this question at me. And i beleive no one has or will ever direct this low stupid type of question.

There is no one from the people except that he knows that lying is a despicable trait. And their is no one who beleives in Allah who is ignorant of the fact that Allah is described with attributes of perfection, all of them, and is free from the attributes of imperfection. His Power, Lofty and Sublime, on a thing with no necessary importance and the possiblity of describing Him with it. His Power is only connected to possibilities and not to impossibilities..