Debate: Ashraf A’li Thanwi and Hujjat ul Islam A’llamah Hamid Rida

Discussion in 'Siyar an-Nubala' started by Qasim Hanafi Ridwi, Mar 20, 2014.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. 'Urs Sharif in Bareilly Sharif
     
  2. Fatawa Hamidiyah

    Fatawa Hamidiyah
     

    Attached Files:

    • 54.gif
      54.gif
      File size:
      103.7 KB
      Views:
      51
  3. Aameen Aameen Aameen Ya Rab al A'alameen

    The Maslak Ahl us Sunnah in our times is know as Maslak of Aa'la Hadrat radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu.

    Imaam Ahl us Sunnah wal Jamaa'h al Mujaddid al Aa'zam al Hafiz al Qari al Mufti al Muhadith Shaykh ul Islam wal Muslimin Imaam Ahmad Rida Khan al Hanafi al Qadri al Barkati radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu wa rahmatullhi Ta'la a'lahi.
     
  4. medni

    medni Active Member

    mashallah,
    maslake alahazrat salaamat rahay
     
  5. Munazirah Debate between Ashraf A’li Thanwi and Hujjat ul Islam A’llamah Hamid Rida radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu.

    A debate was set between Hujjat ul Islam A’llamah Hamid Rida[1] radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu and Mawlawi Ashraf A’li Thanwi[2] in Lahore in 1352 1934. Mawlawi Thanwi Deobandi did not turn up and Hujjat ul Islam radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu delivered such a staggering speech that many Deobandis repented and became Sunni. (al Hamdolillah).

    It was at this gathering that Dr Iqbal met Hujjat ul Islam A’llamah Hamid Rida radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu; this meeting is mentioned in the letter of A’llamah Taqqdus A’li Khan radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu which is available in the book Da’wate Fikr by Shaykh Mansha Tabish Qasuri hafizahullahu Ta’ala page 35.

    Dr Iqbal was taken aback after hearing the impudent statements of the Deobandis and said “Mawlana these statements are so impudent, why didn’t the sky collapse on them, the sky should have collapsed on them!”

    Sayyid Ayub A’li Ridwi rahmatullah a'laihi refers to this incident in his manqabat:

    “Hindustaan main dhum hai, kis baat ki ma’lum hai
    Lahore main Dulhaa bana, Hamid Raza Hamid Raza

    (Radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu)

    Samjhe the kya aur kya hua, armaan dil main reh gaya
    Tere hi sar sehra raha, Hamid Raza Hamid Raza

    (Radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu)

    Ayub Qissah mukhtasar, aaya na koi waqt par
    Tere muqabil man chala Hamid Raza Hamid Raza

    (Radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu)

    al Fatawaa al Hamidiyah page 55


    [1] Shaykh Hujjat ul Islam Imam Muhammad HamidRida radi Allahu a’nhu the elder son of Aa’la Hadrat Shaykh ul Islam Imam Ahmad Rida radi Allahu Ta'ala a'nhu Bareilly (d 1362 AH)

    [2] (d 1943 CE 1362 AH)


     

Share This Page