molana abu hamzah you have not provided clear cut anaswers to sidi abu hasan's questions and references. the honesty demands that first you clearly state your stance in your own words, and then present quotes. secondly, you have been keeping your silence on ala hazrat quotes a) do you consider ala hazrat of such a calibre that he should be listed among those scholars you are bringing quotes from? b) do you acknowledge that your view/stance is not in agreement with that of ala hazrat alaihi rahmah b) do you believe that al fadhl al mauhibi and al ai'lam are machiavellianism?
if anyone wishes to discuss anything on the other thread, you are free to post here. just to keep it a serious discussion and avoid distractions. wa billahit' tawfiq.
We have Alahazrat Imam Mujaddid Ahmad Reza Khan RH who has discussed and closed this issue and on other side, we have Abu Hamza / Asrar Rashid quoting or understood wrongly the statements of scholars. Why is it so hard to see this? Pick and choose, start the day with hanafi madhhab and end the day with hanbali madhhab. This is exactly what salafism is all about.
