Shaykh Asrar is Pir Saqib Student?

Discussion in 'Tarikh' started by Ethical_Barelvi, Mar 5, 2015.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. kattarsunni

    kattarsunni Veteran

    That is not true. Most of us do not know each other. If you knew most people on this forum you wouldn't behave clueless and ask silly questions as you would have known the answers.

    Most of the guys here know the score with Saqib and Asrar.

    So you either do not know us or are purposefully asking silly questions.
    Harris786 likes this.
  2. Sacred

    Sacred Active Member

    Bro most of us know who each other are here and no i am not here to expose people i was saying if it was about that then we could all do that to one another. I warned that person many times in many threads to stop using his vocab

    check those threads if you want and i was not the only one who told him to stop using rude words

    and here is my proof about the photo (you said this thread was about disccord when I just praised pir saqib producing lions)

    Last edited: Feb 2, 2015
  3. kattarsunni

    kattarsunni Veteran

    I didn't mention any photo. I don't care about that.

    I'm referring to you mentioning one of the members whose name you mentioned.

    As for 'exposing' everyone including me then that doesn't mean anything. 'Expose' us then, we don't really care of your childish threat. This confirms you're here to stir trouble.

    To expose who I am you would be someone close to me.

    But going on your method it's all assumption and hearsay.
    Harris786 likes this.
  4. Sacred

    Sacred Active Member

    Kattarsunni chill bro what you going on about? I been trolling the forum for this long?

    If i was a troll i would have exposed who everyone is including you so relax i told you the reason i mentioned his name and i didnt know it was against the rules

    the thread just has a photo ( whats wrong with you?) i told you the account called hamza ahmad wanted to see it

    Why are you so bothered about this photo, its all over facebook for weeks
    Last edited: Feb 2, 2015
  5. kattarsunni

    kattarsunni Veteran

    Sacred is trolling the forum. He is purposefully here to sow discord. That is obvious from this thread and his other posts.
    Ghulam Ali and Harris786 like this.
  6. Sacred

    Sacred Active Member

    Sorry i have a very bad problem with spelling, afwan
  7. Aqdas

    Aqdas Staff Member

    please spell properly.

    don't assume. especially after you've been told shaykh asrar is not pir saqib's student.
  8. Wadood

    Wadood Veteran

    ma sha Allah, thank you for sharing the pic

    Ustad is most visible, ma sha Allah...he looks like a mujahid, ma sha Allah
  9. Sacred

    Sacred Active Member


    Mashallah beautiful picture of the lions graduating with Pir Saab.

    Amazing picture of the young days subhanallah, I am really impressed by Shaykh Saqib for inspiring these scholars at a young age. The caption I read was at that particular time Mufti Monawwar had just begun to study also.
    Last edited: Feb 2, 2015
    inquisitive likes this.
  10. Sacred

    Sacred Active Member

    Then I would assume that he is the student of Pir Saqib Shaami and Pir saab should be commended on producing such an excellent student, that's all.

    Why arent you answering my question? Haq is bigger than families Aqdas
    why cant you just your brother was wrong and is a sulla kulli? if we can say it about others then surely you can say it about your brother?
    Last edited: Feb 2, 2015
  11. Aqdas

    Aqdas Staff Member

    tbh, for arguments sake, so what if shaykh asrar studied under pir saqib shami?
  12. Sacred

    Sacred Active Member

    Aqdas very true, you are right not every caption was right but on Facebook it seemed it was being promoted big time so I thought it to be true. Jazakallah
    But what is your opinion of your brother sitting with wahabis and sulla kullis?

    Kattarsunni thanks do you know what Shaykh asrar studied with pir saqib?
    Bro as a side note don't call scholars by their name, very bad adab
    Last edited by a moderator: Feb 2, 2015
  13. Nawazuddin

    Nawazuddin Veteran

    hehe...if anything, it is more believable that saqib iqbal sb studied under asrar rasheed sb, not the other way around unless you are joking :)
  14. kattarsunni

    kattarsunni Veteran

    Because Yaseen and a few others finished Ajrumiya.

    Saqib invited a few Maulwis to say they finished a few books.

    Asrar happened to be there and was pictured. It was claimed he had studied as well.

    Later on the picture was published in a book with that caption. But Pir Saqib will confirm what I have just told you.
    Ghulam Ali, Harris786 and SufiSen like this.
  15. Aqdas

    Aqdas Staff Member

    so every caption ever written becomes a fact?
  16. Sacred

    Sacred Active Member

    So why does that picture say he is a student?

    By the way what is your on opinion on Arshad Misbahi saab?
  17. Wadood

    Wadood Veteran

    Maulana Rasool Bakhsh Saeedi Multani

    A Sunni Scholar from Multan Shareef, city of saints, and home of Shah Ahmad Sa'eed Kadhimi Amrohi Multani raDyAllahu ' anhu
  18. Brother Barry

    Brother Barry Well-Known Member

    This did actually make me LoL :D
  19. Aqdas

    Aqdas Staff Member

    He's not a student of pir Saqib. In that pic he's 16 and definitely did not graduate at that time. That caption was placed at the bottom but at that time he hadn't studied much at all. He's not done a single text with him but they did do Dawate Islami work together. They both studied under Mawlana rasul bakhsh saeedi.
    IbnKhan786 and Brother Barry like this.
  20. Haqbahu

    Haqbahu Veteran

    I heard something similar a while ago from a fan of Mawlana Saqib.
    He said that Shaykh Asrar is student of Pir Saqib.
    I showed him the profile of Shaykh Asrar on seekerspath and that
    it doesn't say anything about Mawlana Saqib.
    He replied that Shaykh Asrar has studied one text of Aqeedah with
    Mawlana Saqib.

Share This Page