The Shaykh said how can someone from the subcontinent say that thinking about cows/bulls during salah is a deterrent to shirk? - it's actually the land where cows are worshipped!
الشيخ سالك بن سيدنا الموريتاني حفظه الله يبين الحكم على قول الديوبندية: "التفكير عن حمار في صلاتك أفضل من التفكير عن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم" قائلا: "هذا كفر صريح!" معاذ الله Shaykh Sālik ibn Siddīna (may Allāh preserve him) explains the legal ruling on the vile statement of the Deobandīs: "Thinking about a donkey in your prayer is better than thinking about the Prophet ﷺ" معاذ الله Saying: "This is clear kufr!" https://www.facebook.com/728350647/posts/10165468909275648/
Well done to the brothers capturing the responses of the scholars on video. Some of these deobandis, such as hamza maqbul, have studied under these Arab scholars. Now perhaps some of them will see with clear eyes the realities of their 'students'. And a refutation that comes from their teachers and those they respect is more impactful than one from the 'barelwis'. Hopefully the laymen amongst the deobandis will see these videos and open their eyes also. Perhaps if Ala Hazrat had written Hussam today, he would have gathered the attestations of the scholars on video too, due to the need of the times and to leave no doubt. My speculation
A longer version of Shaykh Salek's response to what Abdur Raheem Limbada said has been uploaded on to YouTube. The two important parts start from 07:00 and 21:15. Please share Shaykh Salek's response with others.
إن شاء الله Video of Shaykh Salek will be uploaded soon on to YouTube but for now see it here https://t.me/RealityOfTheDeobandis/628
May Allah bless the shaykh I understand hamza maqbul studied under murabit Al hajj. Shaykh siddina, a fellow student of his, spends a lot of time in America, perhaps he could be approached? Although the deobandi already consider him to be a barelwi and whatnot. The more neutral scholars who come out against these fools, the better. The more of them who wake up to this fitna, the better
ONE of the biggest problem with sunnis is that we do not have good marketing skills or PR management like that of all other groups, especially the devbandis. al-isha'ah of shaykh muhammad ibn abdu'r rasul barzanji is printed with "annotations of kandhelwi" see here, here. ---- the book has hardly fifty annotations in a book of about 425+ pages. [i counted page by page and listed them at 49; one or two might've been overlooked]. i have given a sample of 15 from the 49 which is 30% of all notes. what could probably be the lengthiest note is also shown (see sample #2 below). these annotations are generic notes one makes when reading - i too make many of them and since i hate to write on books i use sticky notes. i do not deny that such notes of prominent scholars are useful and could be insightful. given below are samples from my copy: ===== it is fine. i do not deny that a scholar's marginal notes are also useful. but the hypocrisy of devbandi wahabis is that they would taunt us that alahazrat's "maginalia" is about few markings he had made on his copies of books and mock at it; whereas alahazrat's notes are far more in number than these and are far more insightful. yes, alahazrat's annotations also have cross references similar to above. my point is that deos make a big show of small things; but their hypocrisy is that if we do the same to SOME of alahazrat's books they dismiss it. not to mention alahazrat's written corpus, even a portion of which is published is so much and so rich that only an intentionally blind or a jahil or a jealous person can deny the greatness. abul hasan nadwi and other devbandi were both juhala and hasidin. juhala because they were deprived of the good fortune of reading alahazrat's books; hasidin is that the poisoned the pond. may Allah taala give them their just recompense. may Allah ta'ala deal with the liars abul hasan nadwi, khalid mahmud and the DESERVING OF DAMNATION, ihsan ilahi zahier (alayhi ma alayhi) with His `adl. --- we are catching up. and in sha'Allah deobandis will have heartburn soon. wa billahi't tawfiq.
Only one scholar form india i saw who really was into this was Mufti Akhter Rida Alaihir Rahma who translated works of Alahazrat and presented them to Arab ulema. He also invited arab shuyookh to speak in URS E RIDAWI. Mufti shamsul huda mentions how he invited SAYYID ALAWI AL MAKKI to barrielly in 2003.
The Arab ulema are not interested in this dispute and the deos have done their work in this regard. What Sunnis should've focussed on was propagating 'Brelwi' beliefs as that would've got have got more traction from the Arab ulema and at the same time would've exposed the deos.
Some posters here may actually have direct links with arab shuykuh- perhaps get their responses in writing/video? The more awareness that is spread, the better. For too long, these fools have pulled the wool over the eyes of non desi's- when video/audio evidence is put to them (and the ability of the shuyukh to get their own translators if their is a claim that the video is inaccurate), then where will the deo's run?
The video (with arabic translation) should definitely be spread amongst arab ulema and students of knowledge and their responses taken in writing/on video- then let's see how they try to weasel out of it.
The video has been translated into Arabic. Please share with Arabic speaking students of knowledge and Ulema. https://t.me/RealityOfTheDeobandis/597
This guy thinks it's an acceptable description. This is a beaten dead horse.The quote is from Shāh Ismā'il Shahīd's Taqwiyat al-Īmān like 3oo years ago.It is a simple idea which is universally accepted by all Muslims, although the wording is not PR friendly.For more info, you can read reams of extant literature about it. https://t.co/N72f8Me0NR— Hamzah wald Maqbul (@hwmaqbul) October 18, 2021
Deobandi Fabrication in Sirat al mustaqeem The forefather of Deobandi Jamat , Ismail Dehalvee said in his book Sirat al mustaqeem: “ To get the thought of Prophet ( sal allahu alaihi wa sallam) in salah( prayer) is WORSE than getting the thought of Ox and Horse.” Urdu : Khwa janab risalat maab hee hon, apani himmat ko laga dena apany bayl aur gadhey ki surat mein mustagriq honay say ZYADAH bura hai The urdu word ‘zyadah” was originally used by Ismaeel Dehalvi to COMPARE the thought of prophet [ sal allahu alayhi wa sallam] with the thought of Ox and Donkey in salah ( prayer) This was analysed at the below link http://www.falaah.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=96:thought-of-prophet-in-prayer--a-must-&catid=46:wahabi&Itemid=99 In 1998 edition of this book, this word”zyadah” has been removed. Source : http://www.falaah.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=161:deobandi-fabrication-in-sirat-al-mustaqeem&catid=42:fabrications&Itemid=92
