deobandi liars

Discussion in 'Biographical Notes' started by harun, Jun 29, 2012.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. harun

    harun Active Member

    Has the Indian Scholar penned the critique of the book?

    Akram Nadwi is doing a course on the History of Indian Scholarship and it seems it is a 'hot topic' on Taqi Uthmani's tour of the UK.
     
  2. absalih

    absalih Active Member

    Munawwar Ateeq Rizvi wrote:
    http://www.razanw.org/modules/products/item.php?itemid=54
     
  3. sunnistudent

    sunnistudent Veteran

    Shaykh Abdal Hayy had a mixture beleif of wahabis/ free mason. He favoured hindu stand on the issue of Babri masjid.

    As a historian he has penned down Nuzhatul Khawatir, in which he has given many false report about the scholars of Ahlus sunnah whom he has called 'Biddati'. Those sunni scholars who practiced mawlid , urs have been labelled as biddati'. Allama Fazle Rasul Badayuni [ Rh] is one such sunni scholar who has been called 'biddati'.

    He has glorified wahabi scholars and has given very little and wrong information about sunni scholars.

    Unfortunately that is the only work biographical work in arabic dealing with the scholars of indian subcontinent.

    I was told by an Indian sunni scholar that he intends to write a book in arabic highlighting the historic false reporting and biasedness present in this book.

    It is a practice of these deviants to call Ahlus sunnah as 'biddati'. The Mu'tazilite scholar Zamakshari also referred to ahlus sunnah as 'ahl al bidda'.
     
  4. abu Hasan

    abu Hasan Administrator

    i had the misfortune of reading the newer edition of nuz'hatu'l khawatir of the nadwi father-son liar-duo. vol.8, pg.1181 [yet once more].

    laa Hawla wa laa quwwata illa billah. i fail to understand how people who read qur'an and hadith can resort to lies! it is unclear if abdu'l Hayy wrote it or his son corrupted it - but whosoever said that clearly doesn't seem to fear Allah ta'ala or the day of reckoning. for there are blatant lies and libel in that short biographical note.

    and i don't know how the author of those lines will stand to answer, on the day of judgement. probably they did not know that Allah's damnation is upon liars.
     

Share This Page