Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Refutation' started by Aqdas, Sep 21, 2021.
It’s not hard to guess who translated it at a single glance just by the way he writes ﷺ
The person (aalim) who typed out the english fatwa below.
on page 12 didnt even know that Alahazrats book is called Qawāriý al-Qahhār ála’l Mujassimati’l Fujjār and NOT Qawāmi‘-ul-Qahhār ‘alal Mujassimat-il-Fujjār.
and on page 17 it is called Raddu’r Rifđah, whereas the translator calls it Radd-ur-Rafadah.
This alone speaks about the validity of the translation!
why didnt Mufti Monawar sign on the english version.
his name is not there
nor is Mawlana Arshad Misbahis ?
can somebody explain whats going ??
1)why isnt this fatwa on the barreilly darul ifta letterhead.
2)why is there no sign or names of Ulama who wrote this. Did the current QAAZI Mufti Asjad Raza sign this?
which ulama of barreily were asked to issue this verdict?
There are many typos in the pdf.
jazak Allah brother. can you please also include the names of the signatories in the typed pdf? it will be better imho
This is a loose translation of the conclusion:
In the above-mentioned matters, there are numerous examples of Kufriyat as well as clear forms of misguidance. However, since it is possible to edit and manipulate audio, it is necessary to exercise the utmost caution in the matter of Kufr and Imaan, and all audio in question should first be verified. If the audio has been verified then it is Fardh that he perform Tawbah and Tajdeed e Imaan in public. He must keep his ‘Aqaid, words and actions in accordance with that of the Ahle Sunnat and should henceforth abstain from committing any shameful acts that cause damage to the Deen and Sunniyyat. And despite being made aware, those listeners and Mureeds who continued to support his ugly and shameful actions must also perform Tawbah, Tajdeed e Imaan and Tajdeed e Nikah, and should henceforth strive to protect and uphold the Deen and Sunniyyat…….If he does not act upon this Shar’i Hukm then the people should stay away from him, and not invite or allow him to sit in religious gatherings, nor involve him in any Islamic matters.
Is there a translation for this and will it be distributed to other scholars to sign?