You need to timestamp the original video. It's from around 1:40:00 where MH claims asrar rashid did says its shirk with or without the belief in independence. Although MH can't be trusted, I would point out
Note that i respect the shaykh - i just want to know if the position transmitted is correctly transmitted and if it is the sunni view
https://www.facebook.com/permalink....6Hjvj5WgigU3HSWtRL9dMXaqdl&id=100081813817673 See at the end Shaykh Asrar hafizahullahu ta'ala mentions tasarruf (sorry not takwin but tasarruf)
https://www.facebook.com/permalink....6Hjvj5WgigU3HSWtRL9dMXaqdl&id=100081813817673 Shaykh Asrar here mentions (hafizahullahu ta'ala) that Awliya have tasarruf
https://www.youtube.com/live/Uyv7PP7rNBg?si=fbcfUkzbEuAIl_NO&t=6077 Did Shaykh Asrar Rashid just deny mukhtar e kull and ikhtiyar of the Prophet صلى الله عليه و سلم and the Awliya radhiyallahu anhum? Because here Shaykh Asrar says Awliya have takwin: