Some of the posters here have too much anger and hate like abu hasan and abdalqadir. It is shame that you call yourself hanafi and sonni muslim and show same habits of wahhabize salafize. And very good at insults. I came to exchange some fiqh masaail but looking at the ignorance and self declared ulama shows how jahil some are here. One guy wanted others to fast arafah day of makkah and his local, and he pulled this from some abu hasan and who pulled from his pocket. Go study jassas abu layth samarkandi and other main codifiers of hanafi fiqh before you show your ignorance from Matoridy As for calling my posts stupid you abu hasan and abdalqadir are just angry kids trying to show you have knowledge but are really empty vessels make lots of noise.
who? who did this and when? give examples. self-awareness is a great thing. look within before you look around. perhaps some of us knew this even before you were born. do not assume things. it is not a good habit. it is rich coming from an ignoramus (jahil) or a dense person like you who is unable to comprehend a simple concept from fiqh al-akbar. almost all of your posts are useless and utterly stupid. chatgpt makes more sense. it is possible that some of us might have seen this before you were born. because you write like a teenager. certainly, after you answer AQ's query about the passage from fiqh al-akbar.
I asked you for explaining passage from Fiqh Al-Akbar (you brought it up) on the other thread, and you're drifting all over the forum.
it is ok, i am also not interested in you, you twist and give false and wrong information about sunni islam or you dont know but post as if you know. Sunni Islam not limited to only Shahada or theoritical islam, or label anyone disagree to be khwarij. this sign of ignorant people. who have little info about islam and they write like they know everything. may be you are the UK type hanafi which are known as deobandi wahhabized salafized. Hanfi and Moturudiy or written in english Maturidi Kalam is not limited to One man or one city. It is a whole system developed mostly by scholars of our land. Some people make Hanfi and Moturudiy from India or Pakistan only.
yes we have read this in our madrasa abu bakr and doing notes , We have also read kitab Tauhid of Imam Moturudiy if you have problem understanding with passages, I can help you and explain it you, as it seems most here on the forum have not really had complete study of hanafi or maturidi kalam. There are few editions online like this one https://www.quranicthought.com/ar/books/دلالة-الحائرين-موسى-بن-ميمون-ط-مكتبة-ا/ but i recommend you the one with the notes of great Hanafi Moturudiy Imam from Turkey, Imam Zahid Kawthari المقدمات الخمس و العشرون في إثبات وجود الله و وحدانيته و تنزهه من أن يكون جسما أو قوة في جسم ; من دلالة الحائرين / ; تأليف أبي عمران موسى بن ميمون ؛ شرح أبي عبد الله محمد بن أبي بكر بن محمدلتبريزي ؛ صحح الكتاب و قدم له محمد زاهد الكوثري ] Title al- Muqaddimāt al-khams wa-al-ʻishrūn fī ithbāt wujūd Allāh wa-waḥdānīyatihi wa-tanazzuhihi min ʼan yakūna jisman aw quwwatan fī jism min dalālat ʼal-ḥāʼirīn Author Ibn Maymūn, Mūsá, 1135-1204, author.; Tabrīzī, Muḥammad ibn Abī Bakr, active 13th century, compiler.; Tabrīzī, Muḥammad ibn Abī Bakr, active 13th century, compiler.; Kawtharī, Muḥammad Zāhid ibn al-Ḥasan, corrector.; Kawtharī, Muḥammad Zāhid ibn al-Ḥasan, corrector.; Kawtharī, Muḥammad Zāhid ibn al-Ḥasan, author of introduction.; Kawtharī, Muḥammad Zāhid ibn al-Ḥasan, author of introduction. Place of publication Miṣr Publisher Maṭba‘at al-Sa‘ādah Doctrines, Jewish philosophy, Judaism, Philosophy, Medieval
Im not talking to you until you respond to my post # 20 on this thread - https://sunniport.com/index.php?threads/how-to-know-sunni-from-a-non-sunni.16161/
Have you read the edition by hanafi scholar of turkey zahid kawthari who edited and published this jewish kalam book https://www.noor-book.com/en/ebook-...w-quwwatan-fī-jism-min-dalālat-ʼalḥāʼirīn-pdf دلالة الحائرين موسى بن ميمون يهودي
https://www.academia.edu/6173811/Je...ctual_History_of_the_Islamicate_World_2_2014_ interesting paper on yahood and nasara theologians being influenced by our Muslim mutakallimun (as well as some mutazilites) - by their own academicians only quickly browsed, but this paper seems to (rightly) take the opposite position of ibn taymiyyah and the wahhabiyah, who accuse us of being influenced by greek philosophy and the arguments of the ahlul kitab
