is this shair ok,be khud kiyay detay hain

Discussion in 'Poetry' started by Aqib alQadri, Jul 20, 2017.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. Aqib alQadri

    Aqib alQadri Veteran

    if you find it, please share it.
  2. ghulam-e-raza

    ghulam-e-raza Well-Known Member

    Naatkhwan Hazrat aik Naat parrhtay hain jis mein aik sher hay
    Kyun Aankh Milaee thi Kyun Aag lagaee thi
    Ub Rukh ko Chupa bethay kar k Mujhe Deewana Kch Buzurg iss sher par Aetraz kartay hain. Hazrat kia farmatay hain?

    Jahan tum nazar aatay ho Sajda waheen karta hun Iss se nahin koi matlab Kaaba ho ya But Khaana Kiun Aag lagai thi kiun Ass bandhai thi Ub rukh ko chupa bethay kar k mujhe deewana Ye Ashaar Naat mein parrhna theek hay?

    Is it allowed to recite these couplets in Naat Sharif. A) Jaana tere milne ki, tarqeeb yeh sochi hai; iss dil me banaa lenge, chota sa sanamkhaana B) Kiun Aankh Milaee thi Kiun Aag lagaee thi; Ub Rukh ko Chupa bethay kar ke mujhe Deewana!!
    Unbeknown likes this.
  3. Ghulam e Mustafa

    Ghulam e Mustafa Active Member

    I have read in AL amnu wal ula of Ala hazrath that the word khuda can be used for other than god. I think it has other meaning also. Insha Allah I'll try to quote that.
  4. FaqirHaider

    FaqirHaider اللَه المقدر والعالم شؤون لا تكثر لهمك ما قدر يكون

    Apologies, yes "cares not" is inappropriate at the least. What I meant to say "to seek him exclusively", the common person think he can only be with lord in prayer or fasting. The demeaning of prayer and fasting is not the aim, because we know through hadith and saying that ugly prayer is thrown back at the person, and when one fasts so much yes still not changing their ego, keeps bad habits, and feasts his/her stomach full come iftar time. (I assume, husne dhan, both these type of prayer and fasting were being mentioned.

    Of course once the person does engrave his heart with Zikr isme dhat Allah, Prayer becomes most dearest like how you mentioned, as the dearest of three things to our Beloved Nabi was prayer. Imam Rabbani also mentions that most dearest experience for the awliya.
  5. shahnawazgm

    shahnawazgm Well-Known Member

    This is wrong at many levels. The closest one to Allah is his beloved Rasool (saws) who spent his nights in tahajjud. We should not be making excuses for statements that are incorrect.

    There are several verses of the Quran about salah and prostration and as brother Aqib has pointed out it is kufr to demean this act of worship. In fact the opening verses of Surah Muzammil were revealed to the Holy Prophet (saws) about his praying tahajjud at night further signifying the need and importance of salah!
    Last edited: May 5, 2016
    Aqib alQadri likes this.
  6. Aqib alQadri

    Aqib alQadri Veteran

    the common man takes it as the opposite - just as the fake peer claims. and to demean salaah or fasting, are Kufr.

    the words "care not to fast....." (at least the English translation)- are totally misleading.
    Last edited: May 5, 2016
  7. FaqirHaider

    FaqirHaider اللَه المقدر والعالم شؤون لا تكثر لهمك ما قدر يكون

    This just means that since Allah zikr is engraved in the heart of the person, he cares not fo pursue fasting or prostation to seek him. He is always with him (metaphorically).

    ~ This does not mean that prayer/ fasting is useless, rather they reached their destination through the fast and prayer and the novelty of this has passed and the taste of Heart in constant Zikr of Allah ﷻ is more flavorable.
  8. shahnawazgm

    shahnawazgm Well-Known Member

    From the link that bro Harris has provided

    "But those who have found God’s Name in their hearts
    Care not to fast nor prostrate themselves in formal prayer."

    This is one of the signs of a fake Peer nowadays. When you question them about their obligatory salah they state that they have no need as their salah takes place in their hearts!
  9. Harris786

    Harris786 Veteran

  10. shahnawazgm

    shahnawazgm Well-Known Member

    Totally agree with brother Aqib. It's also a shame that naat khwan such as Owais Qadri also promote Bedam Warsi when singing his poems.

    These poets should also not speak in riddles that sound more like kufr to the common man and when questioned they state that it's a spiritual thing that the common one won't understand (gehrahi hai masle mein)!
  11. Aqib alQadri

    Aqib alQadri Veteran

    This poet (Bedum Waarsi) is problematic - he crosses all boundaries, which cannot be condoned at all.

    His couplets should not be read anywhere.

    I cite one more example in which he claims that RasulAllah is actually Allah - and since the "secret" is out, there is no point in hiding it anymore. This is blatant KUFR.

    Ishq ki ibtedaa bhi tum, Ishq ki intehaa bhi tum,
    rehne do raaz khul gayaa, bandey bhi tum khuda bhi tum.

    We seek Allah's refuge.
  12. abu Hasan

    abu Hasan Administrator

    if the poet was only talking about prostration, it would be different. even the thought of mentioning RasulAllah `alayhi's salatu wa't taslim with a but-khana or a idol-house/temple is distasteful.

    if the poet is among the gnostics, he has an excuse -
    hosh meiN jo na ho woh kya na karey [or in this case kahey]
    but it is not permissible for us to repeat it. whether the poems of ibn al-fariD or shaykh al-akbar, the ambiguous ones are always to be avoided in following the prophetic advise: renounce that which is doubtful, and choose that which is not doubtful. aw kama qaala alayhi's salatu wa's salam.

    that is how i understand and Allah ta'ala knows best.
  13. Yaseen

    Yaseen Active Member

    In my opinion it's not right but I aren't exactly well-versed in the Islamic sciences. Maybe bro Abul Hasan or Abu Nibras can shed some light inshallah.
  14. medni

    medni Active Member

    sorry for the confusion

    i did write that this was a reply off another forum

    but i just wanted to know the veiws of others

    seems ok to me but i think some people have their objections
  15. Assalaam Alaikum

    Thats one way getting your questions answered!

    Answer em yourself! Hehe!

    No offense bro just joking.
  16. medni

    medni Active Member

    Here the Ashiq-e-rasool is showing his love toward Prophet Salahualiwasalm with a great love, and probably it is quite difficult to understand fully common people, and leading us to wrong direction like Kaaba and Butt khana,but there is no relation of either of these, as he means he respect towards Huzur allahualaihusalm, irrespective of the direction, so where ever he see's huzur sallahualaiwasalm, here will give full respect, and you can say the same shair in other way as below.



    Brother, I hope that cleared your doubt, and one more thing, if some shair which gives confusion to the ignorant people, butter don't express those sort of shair infront of them, as that will be utilize by Gustaq-e-rasool to take way their innocent people.

  17. Noori

    Noori Senior Moderator

    of course not.
  18. medni

    medni Active Member

    Jis ja nazar aathay ho sajday wahi kartha hoon
    iss say nahi kuch matlab kaba ho ya buth khana

Share This Page