Sulh kulli Noor ud Deen Rashid

I'm not Sh Abu Hasan but generally, they are excused even if they wrongly pass judgement. But not in the case of Sh Sa'id who openly wrote a whole book on the topic of imkan al-kadhib just to come to a similar conclusion as Deobandis even if they say imkan al-kadhib is muhal 'aqlan themselves.

Or if they defend the Deobandi ibaraat openly.

 

Mawlana @abu Hasan - What are your thoughts about this where Arab ulema side with Deobandis? Are they excused as they do not understand urdu? And if this is the case then why do they even pass their judgement on the issue without thorough investigation? In any court a judge hears both sides and thoroughly examines evidences presented by each side before passing judgement.

 

Habib Umar ibn Hafiz is mistaken but ....at least not as much as Sh Sa'id.

Sh Sa'id Foudah wrote a whole book on the topic of imkan al-kadhib just to come to a similar conclusion as Nuh Ha Mim Keller

 

If someone calls himself Deobandi but rejects all of this, is he still considered a deviant?

From what i understood from Shaykh Noor ud Deen, he still calls someone who holds the views 1-2-3-5 as deviant, as he did for al-Kawthari.

Is it still fair to say that he is sulh kulli? I may be misunderstanding either what he said or what sulh kullism is, but i am pretty new here so looking forward to having a better understanding inshaAllah.

BarakAllahu fikum

 

A common trait of sulla kullis is that their hearts are void of the true love of the Messenger of Allah (saws). This is the exact reason why they find excuses in defending blasphemer groups with heretic ideologies such as Wahhabiyyah and Devbandiyyah. Contrast that with the Sahabah and our pious predecessors who used to...

This Noor ud Deen is no different and is clearly evident from his speeches. Sounds more like a politician that sullah kullis are!

 

If this individual has himmat, tell him to make a video on Shaykh Qasim Kuzaym and Shaykh Abd al-Aziz al-Khatib.

We don't want your advice Noor ud Deen Rashid.

Keep it to yourself.


Shaykh Qasim Kuzaym:


Shaykh Abd al-Aziz al-Khatib



This Noor ud Deen is not only sullah kulli. He is a liar.


As for Tadhkirat al-Awliya and Saba Sanabil, these books have tampering.

 

Jawab to Chisti RasulAllah from Mufti Zahid Numani:

 

Ironically, this was just livestreamed today:

NBF 239- Ash-Shifa, Publishing Fatwa & Shaykh Noorud-Deen Rashid - Dr Shadee Elmasry - YouTube

 

You should alert Sheikh Asrar then.
According to this guy Asrar sahib didn't sign the document and said it was a forgery.

 

Noor is waffling