It would be of academic interest to all of us to know, what is the Hukm of Shariah on Abu Hamza for degrading the sacred duty of Jihad, by relating it to the activities in the Bedroom.
brother Aqib,
abu Hamza's post #6 was an out of place citation - as correct narration of ahadith concerns all of us, more so when the incorrect narration in this specific instance has been abused by dajjal tahir to further his kufriya agenda.
your reply in #7 was very apt
then you guys had some exchanges post #9 onward. i'm not playing referee or taking sides or getting involved in the fight here, but i think you should fight fairly.
from my reading of the thread, the only thing abu Hamza degraded was what according to him is your 'keyboard warrior' attitude, and not the sacred duty of jihad. it is disingenuous of you to suggest so and make a case of degradation of sacred duties or something out of it.
if it was me in your place, the maximum i can say is that abu Hamza's post #13 is a sarcastic jab at me. i would have further added that abu Hamza doesn't seem to think that posting content on the forum or the net is a part of jihad bil lisan, at least by commoners like us. it isn't very clear from the thread if he altogether denies jihad by the pen. i'm not speaking for abu Hamza or his mouthpiece, but i think his comment
AlaHazrat would not be sitting on public forums performing "Qalami Jihaad",
in #19 seems to suggest that (in abu Hamza's opinion) posting on forums/net doesn't constitute the proper jihad by the pen that was done by Ala Hazrat and other scholars.
again, i'm not taking sides or getting involved in the feud, but personally i found it shocking that you'd lay a charge of 'degradation of the sacred duty of jihad' because of it.
Allahu a3lam.