sunnistudents posts

[sunnistudent]

Does any one have the recording where the question to which mufti akmal replied can be heard?

The clip provided by syed muzaffar shah has only the answer given by mufti akmal and not the question.

The answer talks about friday prayers.

If any one has the complete question with answer, please provide the link.

Note: Forum mufti should do research before issuing a "qualified opinion' or he might go answer less like before.

Mufti Alert: read post 7 of kufr returns thread.

Our mufti has already made some 'assumptions' . I hope both the parties consult this senior mufti before they go for debate.

but still, i assume this was in shola-bayani [firebrand speech] and he was not stating it as a sharayi hukm-e-takfir; so it is to be considered sabb, and not takfir.

mufti akmal sahib could consider it as a plausible iHtimal and thus recuse himself from demanding tajdid e eeman of shah sahib.

 

[sunnistudent]

Mawlana Syed Muzaffar Shah has posted the reply which Mufti Akmal gave in response to a question. Has any one got a weblink for the question which was asked to Mufti Akmal?

 

[sunnistudent]

Noori, can I make posts in this thread which you have dedicated it for my posts?

Shukriya. If there are conditions even in this thread, please do mention.