Gangohi dumps his Shaykh's book

HASSAN

sunniport user
The famous Deobandi Saʿīd Pālanpūrī writes in the third volume of his 'Tuḥfat al-Almaʿī Sharḥ Sunan al-Tirmidhī':

IMG_20260127_193842.webp


Benefit:
Some people engage in contemplation [murāqabah] at graves, sitting for hours with bowed heads, while some perform dhikr jahrī. All such practices are unsubstantiated and innovations, from which one must refrain.
In these matters, the actions of any individual saint or elder do not constitute proof. The true proof lies in the Quran, the Sunnah, and the established practice of the first three generations.
When Ḥājī Imdād-Allāh (may Allāh sanctify his secret) published his treatise 'Fayṣalah Haft Masalah' and it was presented to [Rashīd Amad] Gangohī, he did not even touch it. Rather, he said to the student: “Dump it into the bathhouse.”
He further remarked:
“We pledged allegiance to Ḥājī Ṣāḥib in the path of Ṭarīqah, not in Shariah.”

And it true that some individuals, in extreme old age, incline towards certain innovations. Therefore, if the practice of the elders conforms to the Quran and Sunnah, it is upon our heads and eyes [i.e., accepted]; but if not, fling the defective goods to the owner's beard [i.e., rejection].
 
I find this strange that they can easily say that their elders like Haji Imdad Allah and even thanvi were wrong when it comes to sufi practices and istigatha but all of a sudden their elders cannot be wrong when it comes to specific blasphemous statements.

Sometimes I wonder maybe it's all about ego.
 
Back
Top