the soil of madina

[Aqdas]

And I kiss the feet of the men who have been blessed to visit the blessed earth trodden by my master `alaihi afDalus salawatu was salam.

i have heard on more than one occasion that the soil of madina has a distinct sweet smell. who can verify this?

 

[abu nibras]

nikhat.e.khaak.e.tayba pe itr.e.durood
paa.e.aqdas ki nisbat pe laakhoN salaam

( not from alahazrat's salam )

 

[Aqdas]

Are we permitted to bring some home? Wouldn't the soil be sad to leave Madinah Sharif? Doesn't it have the right to remain there?

 

[Juwayni]

Are we permitted to bring some home? Wouldn't the soil be sad to leave Madinah Sharif? Doesn't it have the right to remain there?

Huzoor Shaykh Ul Islam Madani Miyan told some Ashrafi murids who brought stones from the Haram home to return them.

 

[Aqdas]

Huzoor Shaykh Ul Islam Madani Miyan told some Ashrafi murids who brought stones from the Haram home to return them.

Why?

 

[chisti-raza]

I've also heard the same that they miss the proximity of the Prophet Salla Allahu alayhi wasallam.

 

[abu Hasan]

wafa al-wafa of samhudi, vol.1 p.94.

there is a chapter on carrying the dust or stones of madinah outside for tabarruk:

imam nawawi insisted that it is impermissible to carry or take out of the city, the dust and stones from madinah munawwarah.

further on the next page samhudi mentions possible reasons they prohibited such things; and also mentioned that people used to take a pinch of dust from the grave of sayyiduna hamza raDiyallahu anhu as medicine.

---
on p96, he mentions opinions that suggest that if someone takes them out of the two sanctuaries, they should return (those stones or dust) back to where they belong.

====
Allah ta'ala knows best.