hadayiq e bakhshish part1 and part2 were composed and compiled and published in the lifetime of alahazrat himself. the general consensus is that these two parts published in a single slim volume are by alahazrat.
a spurious part3 was compiled long after alahazrat passed away; a work of doubtful authenticity already, which is stroked in bold hues by forgeries of the calligrapher. the stark difference between the first two and the third is apparent - style, diction, poesy and even grammar is sub-standard.
if at all this was the THIRD part, it should be superior, or at least equal to the previous two. but these protests fall on deaf ears and those bent on vilifying alahazrat will grab every sliver, even if it is miles away from the main ground.
the so-called third volume was recalled, the publisher recanted; and published his repentance, but the enemy camp chooses to be blind to all this and blames alahazrat for all this.