Sunnitalk.co.uk

[muslim 1st Sunni 2nd]

The sooner it shuts down the better. The people behind it should really think about what they're doing.

Are they creating more harm than good? do the benefits of that site outweigh the fitna that it produces?

What is it they are doing wrong?

Chalk and Cheese ...

I know certain people will start labelling me a YN mod or supporter or something like that but I'm just telling you as I see it.

Sunnitalk
The hatred that site has against scholars of the Ahle Sunnah is abhorent. It seems they think a Muslim Portal should be about proving others being misguided or non-muslims their slogan reads 'one of the Leading Sunni Websites refuting Deviants.' Just like on the street certain people believe it should be their mission to prove others. First of all, the level of hatred is quite disturbing and by reading some of the posts it seems it's reaching a point where certain followers may resort to physical violence (I sometimes wonder how old these kids are). What is the point of the website do they think they will win over the scholars/public by refuting them on a website in that hate-filled manner it certainly doesn't make itself attractive to the so-called 'deviators' I see no sincerity. There's a method and style of approaching others when you seek to correct them and they certainly haven't learned one of the basics 'adab' they could learn a lot by following Professor Masood Ahmed Khan Rizvi. There's a long list of scholars who have been quite frankly defamed and slandered which would leave you thinking that there only a few Muslims left on this planet!

Yanabi.com
Firstly, I sometimes don't agree with some of the posts or comments on the site but that is the beauty of being a member of an honest and just community. They allow everyone to share their comments as long as they're not foul-mouthed. The focus of the website is solely to make us better Muslims and to attract non-Muslims to the site the academic level of discussions in my opinion cannot be found elsewhere. Islam isn't just about refutation you know, we are allowed to question practices in order to gain a better understanding of what we do and why we do it. You know I was once what you would call a typical 'Sunnitalk' user but Yanabi.com opened my eyes and reflected to me the insular views that I held hence my username. We are all too busy proving others are not sunni whilst we never think to look at ourselves. You will see people from all ages, backgrounds, knowledge, countries participating and long may it continue, if you don't like what you see you can create a post/topic and discuss it without any hesitation as long as you adhere to fair play.

 

[muslim 1st Sunni 2nd]

What some people fail to realise is that being a Muslim involves all aspects of living in this world and not just the theological bubble that some of us make out Islam to be. It's a complete way of life where all aspects of humanity at all levels social, political, economic is included and oh yeah by the way it's progressive and moves with the times there's nothing static about my Islam as certain people like to tell me. Yanabi.com understands this and tries to reflect this dealing and discussing issues that are not simply theology related.

Why do we pretend that Islam is just about rules and regulations, halal/haram when we reply to posts on a portal but in our everyday lives we choose to compromise or don't even consider what our religion says?

 

[Muhammad Ali]

Yanabi.com Supporters can say what they want, INSHALLAH the website will be back very soon. In the meantime you need to tell Mufti Zahid Hussain Rizvi to do Touba and accept Islam again!