i would take what adnan ibrahim says with a bucket of salt! he's the javed ghamidi or that tariq road (khi) sheikh guy of the european arabs! he's based in austria or somewhere in europe. considering his other positions, rifd is the least of his worries, and that's saying something!
13 Rajab marks the birth of Hadhrat Sayyeduna Ali (Radi Allaho anhu) A'ala Hazrat says: The origin of pure lineage, path to the divine Endless salutations upon the door to sainthood The first to expel the Rafidis and Kharijis Endless salutations upon the fourth pillar of this nation The lion, carrier of the sword; destroyer of Khaybar Endless salutations upon the manifestation of divine power The effacer of Rafd*, Tafdil*, Nasb* and Khuruj* Endless salutations upon the promoter of the religion and Sunnah * Rafidis - enemies of the sahabah ** Tafdilis - deniers of the superiority of Abu Bakr and Umar radiyAllahu anhuma * Nasibis - enemies of Ahlu'l Bayt and Mawla Ali ** Kharijis - enemies of Ahlu'l Bayt and Mawla Ali
@Nawazuddin shia could mean several things 1) shia of hz. Ali 2) shia of hz Ali vs hz Muawiya 3) shia of hz Ali vs hz Abu Bakr hz Omar hz Osman so what does shia interchangeable with tafdeel mean in your context. if you mean hz Ali is afdal then he should be afdal also when it comes to khilafa otherwise how is he afzal ? so many holes in your argument.
Read poetry of Ala Hadhrat, Azeem ul Barakat, Imam e Ishq o Mohabbat. It will also erase some misconceptions!
nawaz! do not satisfy your ilmi zawq by reading poetry on the back of rickshaw and wagons, read some good classical books
parwanah gird e sham'a ke shab do ghaDi rahaa phir dekhi us ki khaak paDi do ghaDi ke ba'ad the do ghaDi se shaykh-ji shaykhi baghartey saari woh shaykhi un ki jhaDi do ghaDi ke ba'ad
I'm busy too but still here, in-shaa-Allah will share my humble opinion after your're done. مگس کو باغ میں جانے نہ دینا کہ ناحق خون پروانے کا ہوگا
ok. i was busy last week. i wanted to do the translation of #3 before going to #4, hence i just mentioned the source (for those who might be impatient); and for those who require a translation, in sha'Allah, will do it soon. meanwhile, farsi edition of tafsir azizi: https://archive.org/details/FatawaAziziPersian PDF (45MB): https://archive.org/download/FatawaAziziPersian/Fatawa Azizi Persian.pdf
Out of the three possibilities, when you consider the innumerable times he has done it and the fact that those very same passages nawaz quotes refute his own claims, I think it's highly unlikely it could be 1 or 2. It was intended but I should have clarified it is my opinion that more than likely this is the case with nawaz. It is clear you did not say or mean it like that. However this highlights another one of his problems: whilst yours is the correct way of not jumping to conclusions and considering all possibilities I think nawaz is the other extreme, perhaps because he is desperate as he has no substance in his arguments. Allah Ta'ala knows best. @Nawazuddin pls take note this is the way of our predecessors, to not quote out of context, And to consider all possibilities and not jump to conclusions, in case that is what your are un/intentionally doing. Either way if its 1 or 2 or 3 i think you need to stick to the day job mate.
@Ghulam Ali: you might not have intended it, but you have quoted me out of context. in the post below, you quote me as saying: but the actual quote is: i mentioned a possibility and i did not accuse him of doing it. your citation makes me do it, when i did not. --- nas'alu-Allah al-aafiyah.
Old habits die hard Its not easy when you're flagging dead horses Utterly shameful, this guy has been called out so many times for so long yet he carrys on: 'If you are shameless then do as you please'. Looks like his 'book' is going to get ripped bad, he may as well put in the shredder Its a good thing that he is allowed to post, by answering him you are in sha Allah earning the pleasure of Allah Ta'ala and RasulAllah SallAllahu Alayhi wa sallam whilst educating us. JazakAllah khayr
so here is question no.3: "it is an established precept of ahl al-sunnah that there is an ijmaa' (consensus) of the superiority of shaykhayn (h. abu bakr and h. umar raDiyAllahu anhuma); now, is this superiority of shaykhayn upon mawla ali karramAllahu wajh'hah is in every aspect or not?" the answer to this question by shah abdu'l aziz dihlawi: ==== and here is the farsi original: