Hadeeth Shurb bawl-e-Nabawi

How did you arrive at this [your above p.#9] conclusion and what do you understand by term shi'a and rafidi as stated in my quoted post?

 

so what you are saying is that some people called him Shia but others vigorously rejected the claim and established he is an Imam of Sunnis, especially Sufis.

 

by brother Jackistan of sunnaforum. [Was Imam al-Hakim a Shi'a or Sunni?]

http://www.sunnaforum.com/threads/was-imam-al-hakim-a-shia-or-sunni.799/#post-6857

 

It wouldn't be the first time classical Scholars were labelled Shia and it won't be the last. Imam Hakim is strong Sunni and so is Imam Tabari, another giant of ASWJ who was labelled by some people.

 

Sorry I meant rely

 

Assalamualaikum
Imam Hakim is being labelled as a shia by some wahhabar.He is recognised for compiling weak hadiths.

Can we reply on his hadiths?


JAzaak Allah

 

ji. I didn't know what to say. I should have said urine mubarak.. can you give some light on it..

 

this is not an appropriate title, and why do you put salawaat shareef in a bracket?

have some adab

 

Assalamualaikum

I hope you all are keeping well. There is a hadith where a sahabi drinks the urine of The holy prophet ( Salallahu alaihi Wassalam). The wahabis say it is not an authentic hadith.

What do the experts say on the hadith. Please put some light on it hadhrat abu hassan and learned brothers...


Jazaak Allah khaira.