Question about Shaykh Yahya Ninowy

Discussion in 'General Topics' started by sag e raza, Jul 12, 2011.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. sag e raza

    sag e raza Active Member

    Ninowy agrees with pir abdul Qadir Jilani about The afzaliyat of Hazrat abu Bakr as-Siddiq radi Allah hu Anhu being Jamhoor and not ijma, I thought that's the main problem with him?
     
  2. Mr wadood, what is your problem with Shaykh ninowy (may Allah SWT protect him)?

    Why are you labelling Shaykh ninowy as Shia? Where is the proof? And don't put any more rubbish here.
     
  3. HarunI

    HarunI Banned

    so if attending gathrings with Deobandis doesn't take away the Sunniyat of Shaykh Habib Al Jiffri and Shaykh Yaqoubi.

    why is the same rule not applicable for Shaykh Yahya Ninowy?
     
  4. Wadood

    Wadood Veteran

    That is not affirmation. I told you shia mullas believe in Haazir o Naazir and Noor o Bashar and even say good for saHaba. Your videos have been on the net for a long time. We knew about them before you posted them here.

    Dont act smart and throw straw man argument. Shaykh Yaqubi is a Sunni.
     
  5. HarunI

    HarunI Banned

    I have posted three videos in affirmation of his Ahlus Sunnah beliefs and I haven't got any proof of his Shia or Deobandi Beliefs

    Can anyone post proofs instead of plain allegations?

    Attending Deobandi gatherings proves nothing..

    Few Days back Shaykh Yaqoubi was on Islam Channel which is Non Sunnni.. so will u call him a Salafi lover?
     
  6. CHISHTI

    CHISHTI Well-Known Member

    ....."I have called him a shiite, and he's not a shaykh sidi
    he's also dobbie lover"...

    ...So he's a "Shia" who believes Hazrat Abu Bakr RadyAllahu Anhu is afzal AND he loves wahhabis and deobandis???...strange....not like any shia i've ever come across!!
     
  7. Wadood

    Wadood Veteran

    Every local shiite mulla in Iran and Afghanistan supports Noor o Bashar and Haazir o Naazir, for all the 12 Imams of the Aal al Bayt that they talk about

    And ofcourse they speak good of the SaHaba of RasulAllah salAllahu 'alayhi wa alihi wa sallam

    he loves devbandi-wahhabiyya, and thats all that matters to the wahhabiyya
     
  8. HarunI

    HarunI Banned

    CAn you post your proofs?

    BTW,he is automatically a Mushrik according to Dobbie belief becuase of his support for Noor BAshar and Hazir Nazir....doesn't he?

    and did u see the third video in which he says that Hazrat Abu bakr (Radiyallahu
    Anhu) s the most Afzal?
     
  9. Wadood

    Wadood Veteran

    I have called him a shiite, and he's not a shaykh sidi
    he's also dobbie lover
     
  10. who on this forum has called shaykh ninowy a shia?!
     
  11. HarunI

    HarunI Banned

    any replies to this?

    Don't the people who call him a Shia have a single proof to prove their claim?
     
  12. HarunI

    HarunI Banned

Share This Page