salam, there have been a couple of replies to the last reply from sh. asrar: part 1 and part 2 i can't bring myself to read all of it as it is written in the usual verbose boring manner of the author of that site!
Here is the link on sunnaforum: http://sunnaforum.com/threads/debate-sidi-asrar-vs-wahabi-murtaza-khan.273/page-4#post-2494
wa alaykum asalam let me know if this works: http://sunnitalk.co.uk/forum/attachment.php?aid=1 I've just tried it. It doesn't seem to work unless you are logged in.
Here is the response, someone has uploaded it on sunnitalk, short and sweet: http://sunnitalk.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?tid=1264&pid=6951#pid6951
Part 5 released: http://www.asharis.com/creed/articl...oncerning-the-creed-of-the-salaf---part-5.cfm A response will follow insha Allah.
Part 4 of the refutation is now up: http://www.asharis.com/creed/articl...oncerning-the-creed-of-the-salaf---part-4.cfm Check this: They also admit:
Part 3 to the refutation is up now: http://www.asharis.com/creed/articl...oncerning-the-creed-of-the-salaf---part-3.cfm
http://www.asharis.com/creed/assets/images/asraar-rasheed-coventry-ash.gif The above is an image what Mulla Asrar wrote. Can anyone translate it? It's pretty short.
Bro, that site is run by a rabies-stricken dog. No one has ever taken his verbiage seriously, even other wahabis. 99.99% of the time, he doesn't himself know what he's barking at/about. He hasn't once responded to any refutation of his comments. He's gone silent since Nov 2010 I think, and it's a waste of breath being bothered with him.
Someone has forwarded this refutation written in response to Shaykh Asrar Rashid's short statement on creed: http://www.asharis.com/creed/articl...oncerning-the-creed-of-the-salaf---part-2.cfm The "Salafis" have also put up a screenshot of the original Arabic statement alongside the refutation. The statement was written 6 years ago.Much water has passed under the bridge sinc then. I would expect a response to this in the coming months. The "Salafis" took six years.
