Amazing: Shaykh Tahir al Qadri challenge: Ask! I will SHOW you whatever you want!

Tahirul Qadiri is a great scholar and current champion of the Ahle Sunnah cause.

Yes he made a mistake with the diyyat issue but which of his few current detractors (or their planted internet minions)are perfect?

Despite efforts of a few ulema to have this guy condemned he still seems to go from strength to strength.

Fantastic i tell ya, fantastic!

 

Here we go again!!

Don't suppose we could just drop this topic can we??? After all........you either like him or not.

Let us just try to analyse ourselves first as laymen, rather than to continually look for faults in incredible personalities such as Prof Sahib, who have dedicated their life in the way of The Deen. Believe me, before anyone points a finger at me.....I am nothing but a feeble beginner, but I have seen too many threads on this same topic, which get absolutely nowhere!

JazakAllah Khair.

 

but i really fail to understand what ppl have against professor sahib. he does speeches on things which others identify as Barelvi --and that means Sunni in the Subcontinental context! he promotes and defends our aqidah at every opportunity against the deviants [even if he doesn't name them specifically but it is obvious who he means], he is probably the most high profile sunni barelvi alim known by the arab ulama, him and his organisation have done tremendous written work and yet people still find excuses to bash him and doubt both his aqidah and his sincerity! amazing that we can be so judgmental of each other. Has he made mistakes? I'm sure he has but so has everyone else! Only Prophets are ma'soom. Is there anyone here who really thinks they might not have made a mistake in understanding a point of islam at some point or another...

 

sidi aH,
dear fellow! let me rephrase, "I have never heard him say anything which goes
against what I have beleived and grown up believing to be Sunni aqidah.' As for his koranic exegeses i am not in a position to pass judgement being merely a layperson.

--
i just dont like sunnis bashing each other.

 

How long ago was that. Hes probably a changed person now. I have watched an episode of the Hidaya that they are showing on QTV, and personally it was magnificent.

 

sukut?

What upsets me his sukut on the fatawa of husam al-haramayn 'ala manhar al-kufr wa al-mayn. Here is his stance.

 

and you, i suppose, KNOW sunni aqidah inside out.

i saw a video of the shaykh once describing mi'yraj and was forced to recite istighfar and ta'awwuz a dozen times. moreover, such a 'challenge' is surprising; true, the qur'an has an answer to everything - but to claim that 'i can show you anything from the qur'an' is a bit incredible to me personally.

i have seen his past speeches which are simply misrepresentations of fiqh masters - blunders, if am allowed to say that - and again, personally, i don't trust his understanding of the qur'an. the issue of diyat mainly, where he misquoted fat'H al-qadir among other books.

 

Hear! Hear! Chishti Sahib-well said! The double-standard is staggering and I, for one, am sick to death of this infighting amongst Sunnis. Especially of Professor Sahib. I can honestly say I have never heard a speech of his which has been anything but pure Sunni aqidah.

 

It always amazes that people are critical of Prof. Tahir Ul Qadiri when he went into politics. The people in Sunni Tehreek (who broke away from dawate islami) when they stand for office in Karachi nobody calls them politicians, when Shah Ahmad Noorani stood for office nobody called him a politician...this critisizm is only for Prof. Sahib.

If Islaam is a total way of life and is involved in everything we do then politics is a big part of life and Muslims have to get involved. We Sunnis always use the mantra of not getting involved in politics and yet yearn for rightous leadership or moan when wahhabis/deobandis get in control.

Prof. Sahib wanted to implement Islaamic government yet he is insulted and called a politician and at the same time we cry everyday because the leaders in Muslim lands are western puppets and are allowing secularism to take over their respective countries.

We want Islaamic leaders but insult anybody who goes for that office, if we want Islaam to rule our country then we need Islaamic people to facilitate that rule. We can't really expect Islaamic government from the nawaaz sharifs, zardaris, mubaraks of this world can we?

BTW this wasn't aimed at brother Wadood but at all who soley critisize Prof. Sahib and those who struggle for Nizaam i Mustafaa Sall Allaahu Aleyhi Wa Sallam.

 

Allah ta'ala bless Shaykh Tahir ul Qadiri. He has a beautiful Masjid on the main commertial road in Karachi called "Tariq Road". It is the ONLY Sunni Masjid on that road that was dominated by wahabis/deobandis. The Masjid has by far the most beautiful minaret I have seen in Karachi and the biggest as far as I know.

I hope the students of Shaykh Tahir ul Qadiri do not go into extremes into elevating him for sure I believe that the Shaykh would not like that.

However, in Lahore I was warned by a number of Sunnis to keep away from Minhaj ul Qur'an because of its politics. They told me (and I think I have mentioned this before in these forums) that the movement of Minhaj ul Qur'an would brainwash you so that you could join them for political purposes. This is not related to the fact that the movement is Sunni based.

I told them what about the other organizations running in Lahore. They said that they were talking in general about any political group. Dont join politics at all in Pakistan.

If Shaykh Tahir ul Qadiri has resigned from politics as I have heard then I would like Minhaj ul Qur'an to declare itself free from politics as the Da'wate Islami movement and inshaAllah it will be able to do much better in that country in the eyes of middle class and upper middle class and rich Sunnis.

 

<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value=""></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

"Agar koi munkir hai aur nahin maanta quran ko aur quran ki baat uski samajh mein nahin aati...mujhe Mustafa صلى الله عليه وسلم ki naalayn ki qasam khaRa ho jaaye aur mujhe kahe jo dekhna chahita hai dikha deta hooN!"

subhan Allah! Never seen a Sunni shaykh utter such a challenge before in public!