jake is a moron who has not understood the ash'ari position. it is like someone arguing about relativity solely on the basis of the linguistic definition of "relation".
this thing about gharad/motive is misunderstood by those with superficial reading. mufti akmal also made this mistake and i was explaining it in another thread. https://sunniport.com/index.php?thr...kmals-speech-on-apni-khatir.15535/#post-79261 gharaD as in: 'to gain benefit' is not the same as 'motive' - doing an action for a desired outcome. in that long post jake has demonstrated that he does not understand it, and similar to his devbandi idols, has misquoted or can be termed: improper citation.
where? the guy's a pathological psychopath! on the tweet you linked, he says: now after years of observing mark hanson, i'm really wary of anyone who skirts depth of the discussion by: 'for more details see my article in [western university/academia journal; 95+% chance "peer-reviewed" by kuffar]' anyways, i downloaded the said article, and saw this utterly jahil gibberish as the "conclusion": (note that this is the full "conclusion" in his article; i copied it in its entirety; just not attaching it if there are any copyright issues, but the article is freely downloadable on academia.edu, and you can just sign in and download using your google account; no need to create an account and register) googled the guy's name and came across him here - https://learn.sapienceinstitute.org/about-us/
https://x.com/MMetaphysician/status/1803256657910145520?ref_src=twsrc^google|twcamp^serp|twgr^tweet This guy has been on a decent anti ashari tirade despite benefitting from the legacy of Al Ghazali and the like. Any responses to the above and similar recent tweets?
a zindiq following another zindiq in his putrid belief. https://x.com/ridawipress/status/1803514598122787317 may Allah humiliate these zanadiqah.
