Kufr, Gumrah, Tawatur

Discussion in 'Aqidah/Kalam' started by Aqdas, Jun 3, 2016.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. Aqdas

    Aqdas Staff Member

  2. Juwayni

    Juwayni Veteran

    The Killer Mistake, compiled by Sidi Abu Hasan.
  3. Mohamed shaksi

    Mohamed shaksi New Member

    What does TKM mean?
  4. abu Hasan

    abu Hasan Administrator

    majma'a al-anhur is not the same as bahjah al-anwar. thanks for the klarification.
  5. Mohamed shaksi

    Mohamed shaksi New Member

    Just read a ost of Atabek claiming the Prophets being alive is Mutawatir?

    I do believe they are alive but to say its Mutawatir according to Ahlus Sunnah? Do you have info about it? At best Mashur bil Ma'na, but if one denies this on ijtihad should be khati. Not Kafir. Because the texts are edible for interpretation.

    Next a very weird fatwa that in the UK you can eat untill sunrise? Atabek claimed this, on his own idjtihad.

    I mean there is a consensus that fadjr is present but pinpointing it is difficult. But to state you can eat untill sunrise is to abograte Fajdr itself.
  6. Mohamed shaksi

    Mohamed shaksi New Member

    مجمع الأنهر في شرح ملتقى الأبحر المؤلف: عبد الرحمن بن محمد بن سليمان المدعو بشيخي زاده
  7. abu Hasan

    abu Hasan Administrator

    also, please forgive my ignorance - which book is this? full name and author's name would be helpful.
  8. abu Hasan

    abu Hasan Administrator

    all you need to do is study all the relevant portions in books of kalam, fiqh (about qaDa etc.) rasm al-mufti and of course and of course, the "use-cases" illustrations abound in books of fatawa. specifically, you can peruse the "book of apostasy" "about apostates" riddah, murtaddeen, etc. in fiqh books.

    try fatawa tatarkhaniyah, fatawa qaDi khan, fatawa khayriyyah, fatawa bazzaziyyah and of course, fatawa riDawiyyah.

    radd al-muHtar has a lengthy discussion, so also in his tanbih al-wulat.

    haytami in his al-iylam bi qawaTiy al-islam. and other books of alfaz al-kufr.
    this has four such books in one volume: http://www.archive.org/download/gakgak/gak.pdf

    i have also noted some other works in TKM.

    wa billahi't tawfiq.
  9. Mohamed shaksi

    Mohamed shaksi New Member

    Shukran please if you have more, share with me. Great!

    I need some more info about the conditions of takfeer and process of it. Bahjah Anwar was great, but too concise. Do you know where I can find tafseel?
  10. abu Hasan

    abu Hasan Administrator

    try this one:

    how do you know it? and what do you know about it?

    here are some resources. after you exhaust them, you can come back, i will have more for you, in sha'Allah.
    happy reading:

    sharh al-talwiH ala al-tawDiH by taftazani


    fawatih al-raHmut sh. musallam al-thubut


    hashiya attar and bannani ala jam' al-jawamiy



    kafi sharh pazdawi

    kanz al-wusul ila ma'arifat al-usul (sharh usul pazdawi)

    manar and its shuruh

    kashf al-asrar:

    fat'H al-ghaffar sharh al-manar

    nur al-anwar:

    if the discussion on ijma'a above doesn't whet your appetite, i can give you an extended list in sha'Allah.

    wa billahi't tawfiq.
  11. Mohamed shaksi

    Mohamed shaksi New Member

    Shukran but its too concise
  12. Haqbahu

    Haqbahu Veteran

  13. Mohamed shaksi

    Mohamed shaksi New Member

    Dear I need sources with hukm

    When someone denies Tawatur Lafzi what is the Hukm? Please with reference
    When Tawatur Mana?
    When Mashur Lafzi
    mashur Mana

    When is it Kufr, Gumrah, Fisq etc.

    I know it but I need the resources. Especially Idjma is a difficult one, there are many kinds of it.

    Djazak Allah

Share This Page