https://www.facebook.com/100006510128224/posts/3271598386400467/ So I think he's saying that prophethood is a condition for being sinless, so if it is said anyone after RasulAllah ﷺ is sinless, then this contradicts finality of prophethood because only a prophet is sinless.
I got this on whatsapp today. Don't know what exactly Dr Jalali is trying to do. Even if he is refuting hard core rawafid, their batil aqidah states the 12 imams are ma3soom, and they don't delve into khatme nubuwwat. Assuming they attribute it to Sayyidah radi Allahu 3anha too, same thing, they don't have any connections between ma3soomiyat and khatme nubuwwat (as far as I know). So how/why exactly is Dr Jalali linking the two issues together? Yes he did say he can be contacted for clarification. Why not just release a bigger statement including the purported clarification, or at least a summary of it? We're not watching a soap opera here that we need these cliffhangers!
