a very good read. the hadith from tirmidhi shareef quoted on page 52 seals the discussion for good. If I remember well, I think you have elaborated on this topic in the book Truth About A Lie. Will have to re-visit and check. But what struck me most is that the malayina have succeeded in embroiling the poor, uninformed and simple minded muslims, in a vexing fitnah which the ulama of the past had laid to rest long ago. Both the wahhabis and their 'pinker' shade have spared no effort in resuscitating old fitnahs and that too in times in which competent scholars and mindful and god-fearing commoners are rarer than red sulphur. Fitnah is sleeping, may Allah curse the one who awakens it.