Qabr ki - Ziyarat or Zira'at?

Discussion in 'Bibliography' started by HASSAN, Aug 2, 2024.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. abu Hasan

    abu Hasan Administrator

    it is clear from the question itself that it should be zira'at.

    any dictionary will tell you that zira'at زراعت = kheyti karna

    in the question it is asked: 'masjid banana ya kheyti karna'

    to which alahazrat has replied zira'at karna

    ====
    besides, ziyarat cannot be used in this sentence thus: "qabron par masjid banana ya ziyarat waghayra karna haram"

    no one does "qabr par ziyarat" as in the sentence - it should be "qabr ki ziyarat".

    this and the fiqhi position of the imam concerning visiting graves (that it is permissible), and refutation of wahabi/devbandi opposition is well known.
     
    HASSAN likes this.
  2. HASSAN

    HASSAN Active Member

    In the different versions of Irfan e Shari'at, we see two different terms used.

    In the first question of Chapter 3 about praying Salah towards a grave, some editions use the term Ziyarat whilst others use Zira'at.

    In the old copy from Ridawi.org, Ziyarat is used: Screenshot_2024-06-20-16-34-19-83_58f827c9f8cd1dffd850cad9571f3f22.jpg

    In the digitised edition from alahazrat.net, Ziyarat is used:
    Screenshot_2024-06-17-22-09-30-68_ab7988c7b00b15bc78ec5a428c58236f.jpg

    I found a really old copy on Rekhta which uses Zira'at: Screenshot 2024-08-02 at 20.31.42.png

    In other books which reference and quote this passage, Zira'at is used.

    In 'Imam Ahmad Raza awr Radd e Bid'at o Munkirat':
    Screenshot 2024-08-02 at 20.51.59.png

    In 'Bid'at key Khilaf Saw Fatwey':
    Screenshot 2024-08-02 at 20.54.57.png
     

Share This Page