Recitation of quraan aloud in group

As-salamu 'alaykum

Please note that when the Qur'an is read aloud in the dhikr groups of different salisal (tariqas) this is not done with the intention of reciting Qur'an but as a wazifa. Therefore it would be jaiz, just as the 'uttering' of the Qur'an by a women in her period. But this is not dalil for reciting the Qur'an loudly in group with the intention of reeciting. According to 'ulama it is not allowed to recite the Qur'an loudly in a group, as it is wajib to listen to the recitation made by one - as the Qur'an verse says.

Allah Hafiz
Ibn Amin

 

it is makruh

 

I have heard a distinguished ulema say that the practice of loud recitation in group is not permissible in Qadiri tariqat, while the same is permissible in Naqshbandi tariqat.

I am not sure about the stance of different school of jurispudence on this.

 

accoring to Sunni savants ahriman makruh.

 

:s1:

It's not allowed to recite the Quran in a gathering in such a loud voice that the voices of different reciters clash with each other. In a gathering the Quran should be recited in low voice.

 

group and quran

I read in valuable sunni books that it is tahriman mekruh

 

Assalamualaykum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh,

Please advise, with references, whether according to
the hanahfi madhab, it is permissible to recite holy
Quraan aloud together in group, i.e. in a khatam for
example, where surahs or certain ayats are recited
aloud together. Whether this contravenes the Ayat, "Wa
Iza Qare ul Quran fastameu lah wa ansatu laallakum
turhamoon." i.e., "when the Quraan is read, listen to
it with attention, and hold your peace, that you may
receive mercy".

Jazakallah