Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Refutation' started by abu Hasan, Jul 10, 2019.
What's wrong with GF Haddad?
Unjust criticism of azmi sahib because sharing stage ... When i raised the same thing about asrar rashid sahib sharing with gf haddad you can search the forum how asrar rashid sahib was defended... Had enough of this injustice. It is a shame.
@Aqdas in regards to points 1 and 2, do you have evidence for this? I know the individual in question has links with so called pirs/mashaykh who holds such positions but I am yet to see any evidence of himself holding such positions. Could you please clarify?
Neither of the two are new kids on the block. I find this really hard to believe however if true it constitutes gross negligence on Azmi Sahibs part.
I didn’t know Brother Aqdas was Allama Azmi’s personal owl. Good to know. I might have a few messages I need to get delivered too.
If some of us here also exercised our brains for more than focusing on other (lay) people’s actions, perhaps the result would be deep introspection leading to self improvement or learning our fard ayn.
Is there any proof he speaks ill of Sayyidina Mu'āwiyah رضي الله عنه?
Have you made Mawlana Azmi aware of the above?
If Azmi sahib accepts an invite again from Fazle after knowing he:
1. Attacks Amir Mu'āwiyah رضي الله عنه
2. Denies the ijma'a on tafdil al-shaykhayn
3. Associates with Tahir ul
Then I won't share a stage with Azmi sahib either. Because Fazle is a deviant and I won't share stages with those who promote deviants.
Right now, I am sure he isn't aware of these matters.
Hazrat Aqdas will you share stages with Mawlana Azmi as he attends gatherings hosted by Fazl Ahmed.
Mawlana Azmi was at Derby with Fazl Ahmed as his guest. It is the same gathering mentioned in the ad. This is the facebook video link.
Youtube video link - gathering at Cheetham Hill Masjid with Mawlana Azmi, Mawlana Aqdas and a Pir from Pakistan who supports Dr Tahir
Easy to write all this but hard to execute i guess.
I wasn't aware at the time he associates with Tahir ul. I won't share a stage with him again, ان شاء الله.
This is someone from Pakistan and a visitor. I did not know about him before.
one is azmi sb.
is the other one? is he fazle ahmed? is this the same gathering mentioned in the ad i posted earlier?
Hazrat Aqdas Mawlana Muhammad Aqdas sharing a stage and speaking alongside an ardent supporter of Dr Tahir.
Maybe Moulana Aqdas can seek some clarification from Azmi sahib, or get them to use the stage to refute padri and his fitna. As Abu Hasan said, fazle ahmed and his son are ardent and open supporters of padri. This is not a secret.
Got this on Whatsapp today.
i was told that qamaruz zaman azmi sahib is now a guest of a known minhaji and a tafdili type.
can't talk about his son
can't speak about his daughter in law
can't talk about anyone else but what is the point of being khatib e asr?
after having garnered all accolades, awards, titles, if one cannot stand up for ahl e sunnat or speak up for ahl e sunnat - they should at least retire, go back home and busy themselves reading dala'il al-khayrat instead of granting legitimacy to sulh kullis and wishy-washy types.
sunnis need ulama who can call a spade a spade.
show people the way without worrying about displeasing some or losing favour with some others.
either lead the way by sticking out your neck and be unpopular or stay back at home; we will send dua's for not diluting the manhaj.
nas'alu Allah al-aafiyah.
Are Shaykh Azmi and Shaykh Noori of NMJM aware of the above two characters?
with due respect to his seniority - what exactly are his contributions in the field of knowledge to be termed 'greatest scholar'.
anyone can claim anything but it means nothing unless there is evidence - direct or indirect.
i have no problems accepting someone as a 'senior sunni figure' or even a 'senior sunni scholar' - but to be called 'greatest scholar' in europe, there should be some kind of outstanding contribution in terms of books, students, speeches, whatever. just inaugurating mosques and community work doesn't make one 'the greatest scholar'.
letting children to kneel down before a kafir queen and celebrating christmas in masjids without a whimper is no sign of mufti azam's nisbat. or so i think. wAllahu a'alam.
people may get offended, but knowledge is a trust - nobody's personal property. scholars should be upright and be frank and candid when it comes to the knowledge of RasulAllah sallAllahu alayhi wa sallam.
we are a nation who invented the isnad system and the jarh-ta'adil framework - people sparing no one - not even their own teachers.
all for the safeguarding of the trust.
nas'alu Allah al-aafiyah.
Have a listen to Selma rambling on about Ijtihad between 1.50 to 2.00
At 51 minutes Seyh Ershad Misbâhî describes Selma's father in law as the greatest scholar in Europe and successor of Müfti-i-Ehl-i Sünnet Mustâfa Rîza Han Hâzretlerî
Are these men really the successors of Imam-i Ehl-i Sünnet ve Mücceddidi Ahmâd Rîza Han Hâzretlerî in Hind?
Fatiha i şerife for the release of Mevlana Seyh Hâdim Rizvî Hâzretlerî in his mission to return the Ehl-i Sünnet to the way of Hadrat Imâm-ı Rabbâni Ahmad Fârûkî Sirhandi (rahmatullah alayh), Ameen