MORE SHOCKING CONFESSIONS BY - [PSEUDO] Salaf / Ahlul Hadith Ulama The real truth about Wahdat ul Wujud and Sufism. Mere observation will tell you that whenever a False SECT emerges, it's beliefs keeps on Maturing and evolving with Time to counter the argument raised by Ahlus Sunnah. The same thing can be said regarding Deobandis and Ahle Hadith i.e. their sects are filled with CLEAR CONTRADICTIONS. One such example is that Early scholars of Movements like Salafi, Wahhabi , Taymiyyan [followers of Ibn Taymiyyah] etc were never against Sufism as whole . In fact, Ibn Taymiyyah has a full volume - al-Tasawwuf [sufism] in his Majmu a Fatawa. But the Salafi apologetics try to argue that - ELDERS OF SALAFI MOVEMENT like IBN TAYMIYYAH WERE ONLY IN SUPPORT OF "LEGITIMATE SUFISM" and they never promoted beliefs like "WAHDAT UL WUJUD" and Other so called - "Polytheistic" SUFI beliefs. THIS LAME EXCUSE will be refuted in this Thread. In-shaa-Allah As we have already seen that ThanaUllah [SanaUllah] Amritsari who was the first General Secretary of JAMIAT AHLE HADEES was in favour of Wahdat ul Wujud which is labeled as Kufr by the modern Salafis. In fact, he even gave a Quranic ayah as a proof in support of Wahdat ul Wujud. Now, let's see what other Big scholars of their sect have to say on this Issue. Maulana Abdullah Muhaddith Ropadi , who is known as Mujtahidul Asr among the Ahle Hadees, was a very FAMOUS AHLE HADITH scholar. He has written regarding Wahdat ul Wujud and Wahdat ush Shuhud which are also known as Tauheed e Wujudi and Tauheed e Shuhudi respectively. He writes : "These Four classes of Tauheed are famous amongst the Sufiya. The last two are the same that has been asked by you i.e. Tauheed e Haali is Wahdat ush Shuhood and Tauheed e Ilahi is Wahdat ul Wujud. These terms are usually found in the books of latter Sufis like Ibn Arabi and not in that of the Earlier ones. Yes! Their intended meaning is CORRECT. Tauheed e Imaani and Tauheed e Ilmi is clear , Tauheed e Haali is also mentioned in this Hadeeth – “That you worship Allah as if you are seeing Him, for though you don't see Him, He, verily, sees you” [Fatawa Ahle Hadeeth , page no. 153 , by Maulana Ropadi ] So, according to Fatawa Ahle Hadeeth , which enjoys great appreciation among the Ahle Hadees sect , the meaning of Wahdat ul Wujud is correct and Tauheed e Haali [which is Wahdat ush Shuhood according to the author] is even proven from Hadeeth. [The Hadeeth mentioned above can be found in Sahih Muslim [Chapter 1: Book 001, Number 0001] and many scholars explain the above part of that Hadeeth with reference to the science of Tasawwuf . But, I won’t dwell into that here as we are only discussing the stance of Ahle Hadees scholars on Tasawwuf.] It must be noted that Modern Salafis regard both Wahdat ush Shuhud and Wahdat ul Wujud as kufr and do the takfeer of Big Sunni Ulama and Sufiya because they held one of the above two positions. But, it is shocking that their own scholars believed in Wahdat ul wujud. However, you will never see their scholars accepting this fact in publicly.
He is the guy I am talking about. He is the same person who [from what I have heard] ran away from a debate with Shaykh Asrar Rashid of UK. The worst part is that all the Ahle Hadith scholars of the subcontinent will criticize Sunnis on Wahdat ul Wujud but when It comes to their iwn scholars they will not even make a sound lest they are exposed in front of their followers. As for ThanaUllah [read as SanaUllah by Indo-pakis] Amritsari, then he was one of the biggest scholars of the Ahle hadith sect of the Indian Subcontinent which was mainly born out of the works of Nadheer Husayn Dehlvi and Nawab Siddiq Hasan Bhopali al Qunnuji. They were one of the group of people who were impressed by the teaching of Shah Ismail Dehlvi, the other group being Deobandi. Both groups revere Ismail Dehlvi, however disagreement occurred between his subsequent followers. You can confirm these fact from any Ahle Hadith scholar who has Indo-Pak background. For eg. Abu Talha Zahack , another Ahle hadith / Salafi scholar who has close relations with many big Salafi Shuyukh of Saudi Arabia , writes in his facebook post He also accepts that Nazeer Husayn Dehlvi , Siddiq Hasan Bhopali , Shah Ismail Dhelvi and SanaUllah Amritsari [ThanaUllah] etc were elders of their sect.
Ali Hassan khan, the Salafi-Wahabi scholar, mentions Molvi ThanaUllah Amritsari in one of his facebook posts He also mentions him in high regards on his website http://www.umm-ul-qura.org/info/use...-qura.org/info/user_pages/page.asp?art_id=158
Assalamu Alaikum . One of the main reasons why the Ghayr Muqallid [Pseudo Ahlul Hadith] sect does Takfeer of Sufis is because they claim that Wahdat ul Wujud is Shirk and Pantheism. They will quote passages from our books and claim that the Sufiya were heretics who did not believe in Tawheed. They often present qoutes form Fusus al Hikam attributed to Shaykh ul Akbar Ibn Arabi. But, what these satanic scholars like Tauseef ur Rehman, Abu Ibraheem Husnayn, Murtaza Khan etc. will not tell you that Many Big scholars of Ahle Hadith sect believed in Wahdat ul Wujud. When I say Ahle hadith sect, I mean the sect that was formed by the Wahhabi followers of Ismail Dehlvi like Nawab Siddiq Hasan Bhopali and Nadheer Hussain Dehlvi who deplored Taqlid. I am presenting the following explanation of Wahdat ul Wujud from the book of ThanaUllah [SanaUllah] Amritsari who is still referred as SHAYKH UL ISLAM by the followers of this sect. He writes: "According to this explanation, the parable for Wahdat ul Wujud is that If we put glasses of different colours in the rooms of a house , some white , some red , some green , some Black ,and we put a Lamp behind them , then anyone from outside will see these Glasses in different colours. But, the person with keen observation will preserve the ONENESS OF THE LAMP [lamp ki wahdat ko mahfooz rakhega ie the person will understand that the Light from the Glasses has a Singular Cause]. Qur’an Majeed also mentions while pointing towards this explanation : Allahu NoorusSamawaati wa’al Ardh : “Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth” [Noor 24:35]. According to this Explanation the Meaning of Wahdat ul Wujud would be Wahdat ul Mujad which is completely correct.” [Fatawa Thanaiya(Sanaiya) by Thanaullah Amritsari: vol. 1 , Page no 149 ] I am presenting a scan of the relevant part . It must be noted that scholars like Nawab Siddiq Hasan Bhopali , ThanaUllah Amritsari enjoy the same status in the eyes of Ahle Hadith sect just like Deobandis respect Nanotvi, Thanwi and co.
