Why was Hamza Yusuf refuted on Dante? - Birmingham

its not just an insult, it is blaspheming RasoolAllah salAllaho alaihi wa aalihi wa sallam and Imam Ali karamaAllahu wajhu

i have heard hamza praise dorothy many times in local speeches at RIS and in California gatherings, which i attended with him face to face. he loves dorothy! and his team members too

 

Did any brothers attend this talk yesterday? Can anyone provide a summary of what was said?

Jazākallāhu Khayr.

 

'straight after, he then mentions dorothy sayers.

if some hag translated a work in which someone beloved to me was insulted, i would never mention that hag positively. sayers is the lady who said her most important work is her translation of dante's 'the commedia'. as we know, 'inferno' is a part of this trilogy in which the khabees insulted our master sallAllahu alayhi wa sallam. as a muslim "scholar", hamza should never be mentioning that witch'

http://sunniport.com/index.php?threads/hamza-yusuf-perennialism-and-dante.11715/

 

Perhaps not, but this will highlight that they may just be all talk and no walk. Let us discourage such behaviour on this forum from here onwards.

Which members on here wanted the Shaykh to publicly refute HY and thought he should do so as a matter of necessity almost? I guess now is your chance to attend and see what he has to say.

 

Lets be realistic itll never happen

Do you really think they have the bottle to ask any questions

 

Which members on here wanted the Shaykh to publicly refute HY and thought he should do so as a matter of necessity almost? I guess now is your chance to attend and see what he has to say.

 

Smashed it shaykh asrar!
Someone please take notes of the talk and share them on here once the talk is done..