before we answer zameel's question, let us lesser mortals try to actually understand it better so, i will shorten or rephrase that further more, and ask Zameel to clarify: is it intrinsically possible (according to you/deoband) for the Sacred Pen to have inscribed lies onto the Sacred Tablet? if you believe this to be intrinsically possible, please explain how so. likewise, if you believe this to be intrinsically impossible, please explain how so. we can then attempt to answer his question.
the mutazilite zameel has been following our brother abu Hasan's dissection of his jahl and heresy (this sunniport thread) he has been posting updates on his jahl murakkab (this post on his website), trying to get abu Hasan to deviate from refuting him. on his first update dated january 27, 2023 he has asked the following question:
