Pir Abdul Qadir Jillani Attacks Imam Bukhari

Discussion in 'Bickering' started by AbdalQadir, Aug 3, 2009.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. the two minute video is pretty shocking if accurate.

    1. the tone is sarcastic.
    2. 'imam bukhari has acted towards the ahlul bayt like a stepmother acts'.
    3. criticism of imam bukhari for including the hadith of constantinople.
    3. criticism of the hadith's narrators particularly one umm e kharam (?) for being very weak.
    4. bukhari took all the steps against the family of the prophet which he shouldn't have.

    i'm depressed.
  2. Muhammadi

    Muhammadi Well-Known Member

  3. AbdalQadir

    AbdalQadir time to move along! will check pm's.

    laa hawla wala quwwata illa billaah... some of his mannerisms in speaking and presenting "daleels" are typical wahabi style emotional blackmail and rhetoric and not really academic "daleels", like the part where he mentions the trip to damishq... its pretty much like how two desi uncles get together over some dum-chai and samosas and trash a few politicians... i'm sorry but to a passive neutral observer who is not a resident of the UK and consequently doesn't know him, this video is highly annoying and theres only so much husn az-zdhann that can be shown

    i don't know this "gentleman" but this video was highly distressing the way it is presented on youtube*... and this talk of his doesn't do any favors to the ahle bayt... what is his point? what is he trying to establish by this talk?

    *disclaimer: obviously if it is selective recording and editing and/or doctoring, then my words do not apply and the people who've made this person appear like this will answer to Allah... as i said, i do not know this person... i spoke only on the basis of the youtube video presented - as is - without looking at or listening to any parts of his talk before the 2 minutes and 8 seconds or after it. so if there is a context and a larger aim for the talk, its lost on me.

    once again, if he has a point and there is a larger context and purpose for this talk, can someone bring it forward please. what exactly is he trying to establish?
  4. tazkiyya2003

    tazkiyya2003 Active Member

    That was shocking.
    But is it real or has someone dubbed the audio, because the stream doesnt play smoothly.
    I think someone may have falsely recorded this in pir abdal qadir jilanis name to defame him?
  5. maulanax

    maulanax Active Member

  6. Sunni Tehreek

    Sunni Tehreek New Member

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page