I appreciate the directness and the fact that this was a very unambiguous refutation of HY. I wish more Ulema would do this. I could be wrong, but i feel that our Ulema have become so extra overly-cautious of doing rightful takfir due to fear of backlash and criticism. They would rather remain silent on the matter; such silence is sometimes the cause for more fitnah and misguidance. Or perhaps, they are so humble that they dont feel that they are qualified enough to make takfir?